Why Penetrant Removability is Important, Not Just Sensitivity

  •  

High-quality fluorescent liquid penetrant inspections require strong removability combined with a strong sensitivity to deliver clear, crisp indications

By Tim Blasius, Chemical Product Manager, and Shawn Kilty, R&D Manager

Why is removability important? 

 

 

Removability is important because it helps provide excellent contrast, which improves the ability to see indications. It is the balance between indication brightness and removability that generates a good indication that is easy to see. Sensitivity isn’t everything when it comes to performance – a penetrant also needs to have low background fluorescence (a.k.a, good removability) to provide maximum contrast. The more contrast between an indication and the background, the clearer the indication. Clearer indications mean fewer missed indications and less eye fatigue for operators. 

Each batch of Magnaflux penetrants is tested for optimal removability, and removability is also part of the performance testing to obtain QPL approval for penetrants, per AMS 2644. 

 

What are removability and background? 

Removability is the measure of how easy or difficult a penetrant is to wipe off from the surface of a part during the inspection process, resulting in minimal residual fluorescent background. After applying penetrant and dwelling, penetrant must be removed from the part surface to ensure relatively low fluorescent background remains on the part surface. Lower background results in higher contrast indications, which in turn result in higher quality inspections and lower operator fatigue.

 

 

How is removability determined? 

Removability is tested based on ASTM E1417 in-use testing of penetrants to compare in-use products with fresh new material and ensure the in-use material is still performing to expectations. Magnaflux also tests all their penetrants on every batch to ensure optimal removability for products being shipped to customers. The process for testing removability involves applying penetrant, allowing for a specified dwell time, and then rinsing or removing per the specifications of the method of penetrant in question. 

The resulting background fluorescence after removal is compared against existing standards or specifications to determine the level of removability: lower background fluorescence indicates better removability, while higher background fluorescence indicates poorer removability. These two factors, removability, and background, go hand in hand and are inversely related. 

Note not all parts are equal when it comes to removability, even when the same penetrant is used. Rougher cast parts will typically make penetrant more difficult to remove and result in higher background, particularly with higher sensitivity penetrants. Conversely, smooth, and highly finished parts will often show better removability when all other variables are held constant. 

Get help learning if penetrants are compliant with PeneCert Test Lab Services.

 

How do you perform a penetrant removability test? 

  1. Clean and dry a test part. 
  2. Apply penetrant to the test part. 
  3. Dwell the penetrant according to the specified time found in the part specific technique sheet written by the Penetrant Testing Level 3 (III). 
  4. Rinse the penetrant off the part using the rinse time and water pressure in the specifications for the test part (or remove according to specifications for that penetrant’s method, if not a Method A penetrant). 
  5. Dry the test part. 
  6. Apply developer.  
  7. Inspect under UV-A light and assess level of background fluorescence present. 
Please wait while we gather your results.

Related Blog Posts

Magnetic Particle Crack Comparison

How Brightness and Contrast Impact NDT Inspections

How perception and vision can have a significant impact on probability of detection in non-destructive testing inspections.

Read More...

Dye Penetrant Testing on Pipe

How Low Temperatures Impact Dye Penetrant Testing

Learn how lower inspection temperatures affect the performance of dye penetrant testing cleaners, penetrant and developers

Read More...

Subscribe to Magnaflux News: